|
Real Name: Thomas Martinez Gender: male Date of Birth: May 17, 1968 Member Since: March 01, 2008 Last Signed In: November 14, 2008 Profile Views: 228 Blog Views: 1094 The great comics survey Quiet before the storm Are newspapers objective? Death of newspapers? Nah How to cover a community? Race and the media A brother's suicide My love of newspapers Out of the comfort zone A special night March 08 April 08 May 08 June 08 July 08 August 08 September 08 October 08 November 08
RSS 2.0![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
|
|
The great comics survey
I’ve written before that when I was a kid, I used to love reading comics in the newspaper every day. I liked Charlie Brown. I mean, I wanted him to kick that ball so badly! (That darn Lucy). I loved Marmaduke, the big dog that wreaked unintentional havoc on his owners. Perhaps my favorite was Drabble. I had a lot in common with that lovable loser, Norman. Later, Calvin and Hobbes became a must read for me. That one is still my favorite all-time comic strip. I curse Bill Watterson for stopping it. Lately, until the past year or so, I’ve really enjoyed the strip called Pearls before Swine. That one is really funny, laugh out loud funny. Never heard of it? That’s because we don’t carry it here at the Advocate. One thing I’ve learned as a newspaperman is that you just don’t mess with the comics. You can run a photo of a dead man on the front page and get a few nasty and angry calls. You mess with comics? You’re likely to receive hundreds of calls, and that’s just in the first 15 minutes of the morning. Phone operators actually want us to alert them when we mess with the comics so they can call in sick. So, what recent assignment did I receive (thanks Chris!)? That’s right, take an in-depth look at our comics. So, the first thing I’m doing is a comics survey. It ran first in the Sunday paper. It will also be in the next two Wednesdays, Fridays and Sundays. Take a look at it. Rank your favorite comics. Let us know your opinion. We also want to know what comics you like that we don’t run in the Advocate. Who knows, maybe there’s a strong desire to run a comic we don’t carry. If we find there’s a great demand for a new comic, or that we carry a comic strip that just isn’t popular, then we may consider making some changes. Maybe we can have a Survivor-like contest and vote out the least favorite comic strip. That may be fun. Or, maybe we won’t make any changes at all. I wouldn’t want to shut down our phone system. As always, thanks for reading and your comments. Thomas2 comments from 2 users
1
posted by
justbeachy
on Sep 20, 2008 at 11:28 AM
Oh man, the Advocate so badly needs to toss its unfunny and outdated strips: Hi & Lois, Hagar the Horrible, Garfield, Beetle Bailey, Frank & Ernest, The Wizard of Id, Shoe, Cathy, Blondie and especially The Born Loser. My wish list overlaps Leslie's a bit: Get Fuzzy, F Minus, Pooch Cafe, Bizarro, Foxtrot, Pearls Before Swine and Sherman's Lagoon. I miss laughing out loud at the comics! Where is Bill Watterson when we need him?!
posted by
LeslieWilber
on Sep 16, 2008 at 06:14 PM
Even now that I'm a grownup - a grownup who WORKS at a newspaper, no less - the comics are still the first thing I read in the morning. I'll be brutal: I HATE our comics section. So I offer my suggestions, even though I know it will make people hate me more than they do after a gristly wreck. These are the comics we run I actually like, starting with my favorites: Frazz, Dilbert, Non-Sequ., plus Baby Blues and Zits on good days, although both seem to have fewer and fewer. I used to hate Frank and Ernest, but it's kind of grown on me after a friend who's a fan pointed out how the strip really is the pinnacle of bad puns. There's some attraction. Here's my wish list: Pearls Before Swine (Genius!), Get Fuzzy, Agnes and I'd say Opus, but it looks like Berkeley Breathed is putting his pen away. And I'd LOVE to have Doonesbury. This is going to tick people off, but there's no way papers should still run Peanuts. If you think Charles Schultz is so great buy all his books or read his comics online. There are lots of awesome up-and-coming cartoonists who could use that space. Same thing with For Better or Worse. Lynn Johnson's concept of drawing new pictures for old stories is a whole new level of lame. Why do it? Is she greedy? Egotistical? And the ersatz end of the strip was so saccharine I gagged. I was so happy when Fred Bassett went away, but to replace it with Mutts is almost worse. I'm no fan of Cathy, and I think my boyfriend perfectly expressed my reasoning: It takes a long time to read and it's never funny. ACK! At least when Blondie, Beetle Bailey, Garfield or Hagar the Horrible are missing punchlines it only takes about three seconds to read them.
1
|